Immigration compliance generally

Return to Main Employer Issues page

Employment related immigration compliance has been part of the law since 1986. Initially, the then-INS made sporadic attempts to enforce the law relating to documentation of the lawful status of employees, but those efforts were never very serious. Following the 1990 immigration legislation, the Department of Labor entered the picture with authority to enforce compliance concerning H1b labor condition attestations. As with the INS before them, the DOL only made desultory efforts to enforce the law. 

In the second term (2004-2008) of the Bush administration, the government agencies began stepping up enforcement of immigration compliance regulations. Though their clear emphasis was on workplace raids, the numbers of audits conducted each year grew substantially. 

For example, arrests resulting from enforcement activities have grown dramatically between fiscal year 2002 and fiscal year 2008:

WSE Arrests

With the start of the Obama administration, we are seeing yet another change in enforcement tactics. Both the Department of Labor (DOL) and the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Bureau (ICE) have announced changes in their policies. Both agencies have added personnel to their enforcement divisions. Both have eschewed raids in favor of audits. Both have said that they intend to bring criminal charges against employers in particularly egregious cases as a stronger deterrent to those who refuse or otherwise fail to comply with existing immigration laws. 

The two principal areas where employers can and should expect to undergo government audits are I-9 compliance and H1b compliance. The first pertains to all employers in the United States – irrespective of the makeup of their workforce. The second pertains to H1b visa temporary workers. The consequences for employers failing to comply with either program are severe.